Update: View the series of videos here explaining the procedure for solving the cone in the sphere problem below as well as related questions.

Many Algebra 2 and Precalculus textbooks have begun to include those challenging 3-dimensional geometry questions involving 2 or more variables and/or constants. However, we know from the difficulty that calculus students continue to have with these, that we need to do more before students do their first optimization problems in calculus. You know the kind: Determine the radius of the __________ of maximum volume that can be inscribed in a _________ of radius R. These problems have fallen out of favor somewhat with the AP Development Committee, perhaps because they lack that real-world flavor or perhaps because they had become predictable or perhaps too hard. I would argue they have been part of the rites of passage for calc students for many generations for a reason - they blended the spatial reasoning of geometry with the need to identify variable relationships and reduce the number of conditions down to one function of one variable if possible. In other words, they help to develop mathematical sophistication. I 'cut my teeth' on these -- did you? Any calculus teachers reaching this topic yet in AP Calc?

Anyway here's an activity for you Algebra 2 or Precalculus students to prepare them for these challenges. As usual we proceed from the concrete (i.e., given numerical dimensions) to the abstract. Rather than attempt to draw the diagram, which is fairly challenging for me given the tools I have, I will describe the problem verbally. Good luck!

STUDENT ACTIVITY

(1) A right circular cone of height 32 is inscribed in a sphere of diameter 40.

Note: Students need to learn how to make a diagram of this problem situation.

(a) Determine the radius of the cone.

(b) Determine the volume of the cone. [Imagine asking students to memorize the formula!]

(c) Keep the diameter of the sphere at 40. This time, determine both the radius and volume of the inscribed cone whose height is 80/3. The numbers are messy but try to work in exact form (fractions, radicals) before rushing to the calculator to convert everything to decimals. Oh well, we all know what will happen here!

(d) Try another value for the height of the cone, keeping the diameter of the sphere at 40. See if you can produce a volume greater than in (c). Any conjectures?

(2) We could throw in an intermediate step by using a parameter R to denote the radius of the sphere, and use numerical values for different possible heights of the cone, but I'll leave that to the instructor. Instead, we'll jump to the abstract generalization:

A right circular cone of height h is inscribed in a sphere of radius R.

(a) Express the radius, r, of the cone in terms of R and h.

(b) Express the volume, V, of the cone as function of h alone (R is a constant here).

(c) Use your expression for r and your function for V to verify your results in (1).

(d) Calculus Students: You know what the question will be! Oh, alright:

Determine the dimensions and volume of the right circular cone of maximum volume that can be inscribed in a sphere of radius R. Anything strike you as interesting in this result?

## Saturday, November 17, 2007

### The Classic Cone Inscribed in the Sphere Problem: Developing Relationships Before Calculus

Posted by Dave Marain at 7:36 AM

Labels: calculus, cone, functional relationships, geometry, optimization, precalculus, sphere

Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

## No comments:

Post a Comment